Sunday, July 31, 2016

JODOROWSKY AND PSYCHOMAGIC

A. JODOROWSKY from Google images
 
 
 

PSYCHOMAGIC – THE NEW NAME FOR PSYCHOTHERAPY?


This blog has a very intriguing topic. In the last blog, you were able to reflect on what is psychotherapy doing in the 21st century. It turns out (as studies reveal) that it is mostly useless and it has grown into an industry where the ‘per hour’ fee is god!

In July of this year, I and my family travelled to Canada. Travelling from Brisbane to Vancouver was a very trying exercise. However, in the 14 hours sitting, reading, watching movies I had a feeling that the long trip was acceptable. This air plane time also gave me a “me time” – a time for reflection and inner speculation about life.

One of the most interesting reflections and my awareness, while, in Toronto, was the amazing speed of life among the people living there. Everybody was rushing somewhere, no matter of their colour or background. Everybody is busy moving somewhere and doing something. This made me think of the “ZEN Reality” book I was reading. The author, Robert Powel, as early as 1975, commented about how people have invented ways of improving and changing life’s purpose by creating a rush of excitement that builds a ‘curtain’ behind which is found the ‘ultimate end’ that makes improving on Nature a futile task. He states: 

“Facing the futility of constant ‘rush’ is not to face the reality of death from which we try to run away all of our lives. Nor we do realize that it is exactly this feverish drive for security that is causing the insecurity and fears which constitute the underlying neurosis of modern man” (P.18,1975).

The reality is that most people in this world are seeking to get out from their real or imagined troubles; maybe a slight relief from the pressures of daily living and the usual stress of work and relationships, so they will seize at anything that will give them some rest, some comfort. Perhaps they may seek a way of inflating their ego or resolve issues about their low self-esteem. Or a seek belief system that will ‘guarantee’ a hereafter in a promised paradise. All these ways are an escape from reality and a temporary comfort that does not resolve the unconscious conflicts that are still there. Seeking comfort and the seeking of truth are not compatible.

Some individuals seek the comfort in psychotherapy and we now have a huge industry in the developed world marketing self-help books, retreats, workshops, courses on miracles and personal therapies. All available for a price.

In my 35 years working as a gestalt therapist and trainer in several countries and teaching at the University of Toronto, Canada and in Queensland, I had a lot of opportunities to research and seek Wisdom by meeting many Gurus and renowned teachers. One such wise man is Alejandro Jodorowsky. Born in Chile, adopted Mexico in his early life and now residing in Paris, France. His long and creative life is available in several books in Spanish, French and English. Jodorowsky begun as an actor, then director, artist, master in Tarot reading and finally creator of a very special therapy of his own called PSYCHOMAGIC. And so begun his own brand of therapy and healing.

Jodorowsky’s premise is based on his long experience working with people in many countries and cultures. The objective of Psychomagic is to heal and resolve personal blocks that produce body, mind and spirit symptoms that prevent us to lead a healthy and satisfying life. The key that opens the ‘doors’ of perception (and blocks) is the recognition that the unconscious responds equally to symbolic acts as to actual experienced reality. The symbol is the reality and therefore the appropriate symbolic ritual (therapy) can modify and clear the consciousness traumas and introjected material accumulated over the years and that stops us from growing and developing further as human beings.

Jodorowsky also believes that many attitudes, character traits and painful memories are set in our unconscious and need to be taken back to at least four generations of the client’s family constellation. For example, if your grandfather sat on the same chair all his life and used a stick to punish you as a child, now every time you see that chair you will explode into anger and resentments and you are not aware why you feel that way.

Then, if you are guided to break that chair into many pieces and throw it out, you will feel very relieved and free of anger. Our unconscious experiences this act of destruction as if you actually destroyed your grandfather. Many healing rituals take that same pattern. Gestalt therapy developed by Fritz Perls also uses similar strategies called ‘experiments’.

To understand the deep meanings of symbolic work, Jodorowsky, (just as Jung), begun to study the symbolism of the TAROT cards and wrote a comprehensive book on the subject. He memorized all the cards and did readings for free in Paris. Soon he was asked by his clients to help them with many personal problems and he started to ‘prescribe’ ritual tasks to enable the symbol to emerge from the unconscious and heal the person or solve the problem.

“the spirit bird has to be liberated from the rational cage”

 

Thus, the whole experiment of Psychomagic was dedicated to break the logical (cognitive) tradition of modern therapies and open up the unconscious symbolic meanings that enable the client to heal. We seem to believe that we are better than any electronic or artificial intelligence computer, but we are not aware that the average person is possessed and enslaved not only by his possessions, but worse still by his thoughts and emotions. We are ‘programmed’ by our parents, school, culture and religion. This creates an automatic response to any life situation based on the accumulated introjects.

Jodorowsky sees himself as the servant of truth. He not only developed an effective therapy that he named “Psychomagic”, but also he created the ‘Panic Theatre’, a kind of group therapy as theatre and directed several films like EL TOPO and the HOLY MOUNTAIN (see Amazon.com) and wrote many books on a variety of topics. His critics described him as “El Loco” and he felt good to be called a ‘wise madman’ for the wise fool is the zero card in the Tarot. The start of something new.

As a wise master, Jodorowsky summarizes the concept of “know thyself” as: “to know yourself signifies seeking the truth: that you are the Universe, you do not have any limits (you are limitless) because we all are united to the UNIVERSE like all organisms. Time is my life, what happens is my life! If I know myself, then I am the actor and the spectator, what is the known and what is the unknown, all at the same time. It is not just knowledge – it is pure consciousness”.


THE GUIDE BOOK TO PSYCHOMAGIC

Having initiated the reader to the concept and idea of Psychomagic, I am offering here the Introduction to the full text of the book by Alejandro Jodorwosky. The book is available on Kindle books (Amazon.com). Reflect on this short item and let me know your opinion.

He states: “Freeing the shackles of memory after having studied and memorized the seventy-eight Arcana of the Tarot of Marseille, I signed a contract with myself: “Once per week, in whatever popular café, I will give free Tarot readings. This I will do until the end of my life.” I have been completing this promise for more than thirty years. I turned the Tarot reading into a kind of synthetic psychoanalysis that I call “tarology.” Essentially, the goal of tarology is not to guess the future but rather, guided by the Arcana, question the consultant about the past in order to help him or her solve current problems. People of all ages, nationalities, and social, economic, and consciousness levels come to the café where I read their Tarot. There is no lack of those who ask for my advice (the background being a need for permission to do what one dares not do) or for a divination (as positive as possible). I must, therefore, frame each question. For example:

 “Am I going to meet a man?” - I cannot tell you if you are going to meet a man, but I can tell you why you haven’t met one.

“Should I leave my wife and children for a lover?” - I cannot tell you if you should or should not do this or that thing, but I can tell you the reasons that you have to continue living with your family and the reasons that you have for going with the other. Weighing the advantages and disadvantages of both, you must choose what most suits you.

All predictions and advice are takeover attempts designed by the Tarot reader to convert the consultant into the “magician’s” subject. When the consultant no longer considers the unconscious an enemy and loses the fear of being him or herself, the consultant can uncover the trauma causing the suffering. When this happens, he or she tends to ask for the solution.

 “Okay, finally I know I am in love with my mom, which impedes my forming a stable relationship. Now, what do I do?”

 “Yearnings to give old men oral sex torment me because, when I was a child, my grandfather put his penis in my mouth. How do I liberate myself from this?”

 Having confirmed to myself that sublimating the undesirable urge either through an artistic activity or through acts of social service does not eliminate repressed desires, I invented Psychomagic.

Psychoanalysis is a technique that heals through words. The consultant, who is called “the patient,” sits back in a chair or on the sofa. The psychoanalyst is, at no time, allowed to touch the patient. To free the patient from his or her painful symptoms, he or she is only asked to recall dreams, take note of slips and accidents, separate from the language of the will, and say, without breaks, whatever comes to mind. After a long time of confusing monologues, the patient sometimes manages to revive a recollection, buried in the depths of his or her memory. “They changed my nanny.” “My little brother destroyed my dolls.” “They forced me to live with my smelly grandparents.” “I surprised my father making love to a man,” and so on. The psychoanalyst— who helps the patient progress by converting the messages sent by the unconscious into a reasoned discourse— believes that, once the patient discovers the cause of his or her symptoms, the patient can eliminate them.

But it does not end like this! When an unconscious urge emerges, we can only be released by fulfilling the urge. Psychomagic proposes that we act, not just talk. The consultant, following a path contrary to that of psychotherapy, instead of teaching the unconscious to speak a rational language, learns the language of the unconscious, which is composed not only of words but also actions, images, sounds, smells, tastes, or tactile sensations.

The unconscious is capable of accepting symbolic or metaphoric fulfilment: a photograph of someone can represent the actual person or a part can represent the whole (such as witches casting a spell with hairs of their potential victim). The unconscious projects, from memory, the person onto another being or object. The creators of psychodrama realized that someone who agrees to play the role of a relative can provoke deep reactions from a consultant, as if the relative were standing there in person. Punching a cushion produces relief from anger toward an abuser. But to achieve good results, the person who punches the cushion must, in a way, free herself from any morality imposed by the family, society, religions and culture. If the consultant does this, she can, without fear of punishment, accept her (always amoral) inner urges. For example, if someone wants to eliminate his little sister, because she attracts the mother’s attention, and pins a photograph of the little one onto a melon and busts the fruit apart with a hammer, his unconscious assumes the crime is done. This way, the consultant feels liberated.

 It is understood in Psychomagic work that those who populate the internal world (the memory) are not those who populate the external world. Traditional magic and witchcraft work with the exterior world, believing in the ability to acquire supernatural powers by way of superstitious rituals in order to influence things, events, and beings. Psychomagic works with the memory. Given the previously cited case, it is not about eliminating the flesh-and-blood little sister (who is now an adult) but about eliciting a change in memory— as much in the image of the hated one when she was young as in the accumulated feelings of helplessness and rage in the one who hates.

To change the world, it is necessary to begin by changing ourselves. Images retained in the memory are accompanied by perceptions of ourselves at the moment when we had the experiences. When we remember our parents just as they acted during our childhoods, we do so from an infantile point of view. We live accompanied or dominated by a group of egos at different ages— all of them manifestations of the past. The goal of psycho-magic is to convert the consultant into his or her own healer and to assure that the consultant is placed within his or her adult ego: the ego that cannot occupy any other place but the present.

I began to propose acts of Psychomagic to my Tarot consultants. They were custom tailored, corresponding to each person’s character or story. I wrote about some of these experiences in my books “Psychomagic” and “The Dance of Reality”, which had a large impact. The requests for help increased, so much so that I was not able to respond to them all. For those with whom I had time to work, I requested that they, after fulfilling the act, send me a card describing the results. Based on the acts that had a healing effect, I then began to compile Psychomagic tips that could be used by a large number of people.” In this way Jodorowsky is sharing his work and wisdom  in a practical ‘manual’ that is now published in English.

 

Jodorowsky, Alejandro. Manual of Psychomagic: The Practice of Shamanic Psychotherapy . Inner Traditions/Bear & Company. Kindle Edition.

 

 

 


Thursday, June 2, 2016

FROM PSYCHOTHERAPY TO PSCYCHOMAGIC


“PSYCHOTHERAPY” IS IN NEED OF A NEW NAME

REFLECTIONS YARO, JUNE 2016

 

SHAMAN IMAGE 

 

“The truth learned from another is of no value and the only truth, which is living and effective, which is of value; is the truth that we ourselves discover”
Tibetan Buddhist Masters

 

 BEGINNINGS

The most ancient thinking about the way we develop as human beings, is recorded in the oral teachings by Tibetan Buddhist Masters. Today, these teachings resemble a lot the explorations of the Existential writers like Carl Rogers, Rollo May A. Maslow, Fritz Perls and others. These modern day Masters agree with the old Masters that we will not be able to understand human consciousness and behaviour (as well as the disturbances) through the so called Cartesian-Newtonian science. This science is suitable to the physical realm and not applicable to all human understanding.  Granted, that the recent brain research has begun to clearly connect human behaviour with brain functioning, but the area of consciousness and unconsciousness is still a big mystery to most research.
In this age of alternative therapies, we are still dipping into the ‘old’ philosophical theories of the existentialists like F. Nietzsche, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Martin Buber, Carl Jung, Erich Fromm, Karen Horney, Melanie Klein, A. Maslow and many others.
Yet, those of us who studied and practice gestalt therapy, have realised (from experience) that ‘truth’ is not contained in the vast literature but in the connection or contact with our fellow human being.

THE AESTHETICS OF CONTACT

In the practice of psychotherapy (to use a common word) we learned that the main key  component of healing is the quality of the relationship we develop with our client (see the previous blog post). However, how do we investigate and test this truth? It is a phenomenon that arises and disappears around us at all times.
The reply to the above question is: to connect first with your senses. We see, hear, taste, smell, hear, touch and feel the world around us. We give names to the various items we get in contact with. We classify and compare all with similar objects and thus become familiar with our world as we grow up and this familiar world becomes our reality.
Yet, many say that our senses do not reveal the whole truth; for example: we may be walking on a country road and in the distance we notice a fleck of green standing out in a yellow field. This little green fleck appears to be like a tree. The idea of the tree in our mind is the result of our mind coordinating various memories of green and it comes up now as a tree. We have combined several elements of memory, habit, earlier experiences etc, that led us to form an image of a tree. Nevertheless, these are only approximations of a probable object and if we walk closer and closer it may be seen as a tree; but this is not a certainty, on closer look we may discover that the green fleck turns out to be a green tent, a painted roof or anything green but a tree.
Therefore, reality may be understood as a mystery. We cannot think of anything, imagine anything, feel anything without immediate INTERPRETATION. This actually ‘destroys or deconstructs’ all into elements making reality inexplicable – it may be said: IT IS MAGIC!

PSYCHOTHERAPY

The term psychotherapy is derived from Ancient Greek psyche (ψυχή meaning "breath; spirit; soul") and therapeia (θεραπεία "healing; medical treatment"). The Oxford English Dictionary defines it now as "The treatment of disorders of the mind or personality by psychological methods.”
So, psychotherapy is the use of psychological methods, particularly when based on regular personal interaction, to help a person change and overcome problems in desired ways. Psychotherapy aims to increase each individual's well-being and mental health, to resolve or mitigate troublesome behaviours, beliefs, compulsions, thoughts, or emotions, and to improve relationships and social functioning. Certain psychotherapies are considered evidence-based for treating some diagnosed mental disorders.
Today,there are over a thousand different treatments named psychotherapies, some being minor variations while others are based on very different conceptions of psychology, ethics (how to live) or self-help techniques. Most involve one-to-one sessions between client and therapist but some are conducted with groups, including families. Psychotherapists may be mental health professionals or come from a variety of other backgrounds, and depending on the jurisdiction may be legally regulated, voluntarily regulated or unregulated (and the term itself may be protected or not).


GENERAL CRITIQUES

Some are sceptical of the healing power of psychotherapeutic relationships. Some dismiss psychotherapy altogether in the sense of a scientific discipline requiring professional practitioners, instead favouring biomedical treatments. Others have pointed out ways in which the values and techniques of therapists can be harmful as well as helpful to clients (or indirectly to other people in a client's life).
On the other hand, some argue that psychotherapy is under-utilized and under-researched by contemporary psychiatry and psychology despite offering more promise than stagnant medication. In 2015 the US National Institute of Mental Health is allocating only 5.4% of its budget to new clinical trials of psychotherapies (medication trials are largely funded by pharmaceutical companies). This is the case in most countries, despite plentiful narrative evidence that psychotherapy can work and that patients are more likely to prefer them.
Further critiques have emerged from feminist, constructionist and discursive sources. Key to these is the issue of power. In this regard there is a concern that clients are persuaded—both inside and outside the consulting room—to understand themselves and their difficulties in ways that are consistent with therapeutic ideas. This means that alternative ideas (e.g., feminist, economic, spiritual) are sometimes implicitly undermined. Critics suggest that we idealize the situation when we think of therapy only as a helping relationship - arguing instead that it is fundamentally a political practice, in that some cultural ideas and practices are supported while others are undermined or disqualified, and that while it is seldom intended, the therapist-client relationship always participates in society's power relations and political dynamics. A noted academic who espoused this criticism was Michel Foucault.

GESTALT THERAPY

Gestalt Therapy is a fairly new development in the modern experiential and existential therapies. The founder, Dr. Fritz Perls was a true ‘magician’ in working with a small group. When we look at his films made in the 70’s at Esalen CA, where he worked and trained therapists in the new method, it is evident that Perls' real power was in his capacity to make contact with the essence of people.
In a real sense, Perls took therapy off the couch and introduced the new structure where  the therapist and client are facing each other.  A client of Fritz wrote: "His obsession became finding the truth and beauty in the world.  His greatest joy was when he released love entrapped by hate and fear.  He had faith that when the negative was purged, the basic good of man emerged" That can be interpreted as psychomagic!
 The use of the ‘Empty Chair’ by Fritz, was a new tool that defined the practice. This technique or chairwork is typically used when a client might have deep rooted emotional problems from someone or something in their life, such as relationships with themselves, with aspects of their personality, their concepts, ideas, feelings, dreams etc., or other people in their lives. The purpose of this technique is to get the client to think about their emotions and attitudes. Common things the patient addresses in the empty chair are another person, aspects of their personality, a certain feeling etc. They may also move between chairs and act out two or more sides of a discussion, typically involving the client and person significant to them. It uses a passive approach to opening up the client’s emotions and pent up feelings so they can let go of what they have been holding back. The purpose of the technique is so the client will become more in touch with their feelings and have an emotional conversation that clears up any long held feelings or reactions to the person or object in the chair.  When used effectively, it provides an emotional release and lets the client move forward in their life.

There is no doubt that this method deserves the name:  PSYCHOMAGIC!

 
PSYCHOMAGIC

Psychomagic is the name of a therapeutic practice used by Alejandro Jodorowsky. The technique is considered useful in psychotherapy. It combines art, Eastern philosophies (particularly Zen Buddhism), mysticism, shamanic ritual and modern psychotherapy to heal patients with emotional problems. The principle relies on the belief that the unconscious mind takes a symbolic act as a fact. So a symbolic act could accordingly help solve some types of non-rational conflicts. These acts are prescribed by the therapist after having studied the patient's personality and family tree.
Jodorowsky moved into this therapeutic work in three areas: psychomagic, psychogenealogy and initiatic practice. Psychomagic aims to heal psychological wounds suffered in life. This therapy is based on the belief that the performance of certain acts can directly act upon the unconscious mind, releasing it from a series of traumas, some of which practitioners of the therapy believe are passed down from generation to generation. (I suggest that you reflect on the ‘Inner Child’ theory.)
Psychogenealogy includes the studying of the client's personality and family tree in order to best address their specific sources. It is similar, in its phenomenological approach to genealogy, to the Family Constellations pioneered by Bert Hellinger.
Initiatic Practice, this consists of determining the person’s problem using such diagnostic tool as the Tarot cards, dream journal and some healing rituals based on shamanic practices.
Jodorowsky has several books on his therapeutic methods, including Psicomagia: La trampa sagrada (Psychomagic: The Sacred Trap) and his autobiography, La Danza de la Realidad (The Dance of Reality), which he was filming as a feature-length film in March 2012. To date he has published more than 23 novels and philosophical treatises, along with dozens of articles and interviews. His books are widely read in Spanish and French, but are for the most part unknown to English-speaking audiences. (Wikipedia).
In conclusion, we all know, in this world of instant information, that not all alternative therapies nor medical drugs can solve all the complex issues of a human being. However, Psychomagic therapy is another useful tool that when used well, can solve or ameliorate many sufferings in individuals families and even societies.

 

The July issue of this  blog will describe ways of practicing   PSYCHOMAGIC.
 
 
 
 

Saturday, April 30, 2016

THE FOOL - DREAMS AND NIGHTMARES


 
 
TAROT AND THE FOOL

The cards called the TAROT have no known origin. Yet, it is a very powerful mystical tool. From its earliest creation (some say Egypt) the TAROT was infused with highly psychic images meant to provoke particular energies manifesting themselves as thoughts and feelings. Just like a dream image, the Tarot images include universal symbols also called Archetypes.

This article is not meant to reflect on the TAROT and its meaning but begin a thinking process about how images are reflected in our dreams. So we begin to reflect on the FOOL or Madman. It is the only card out of the 22 major arcana that has no number – only 0. The FOOL cannot be pinned down to any interpretations and is an open symbol. It may represent and unlimited energy, total freedom, holy madness, chaos and also the primary creative and destructive energy.

The FOOL walks on an unknown path. We may say his journey is about all paths. He is the eternal traveller that just roams the world without a specific goal. Or perhaps he is a pilgrim walking towards an unspecified sacred place. Or, again, he is a madman that is walking toward his own destruction.

However, he is also a symbol representing a young dreamer. Someone that is free like a bird. Nothing is blocking him - he simply follows the cosmic life energy. The FOOL is also a musician represented by the bells attached to his dress. As we look at the figure, we may also notice the three elements of creation (manifestation): Creation, Conservation and Destruction. His path includes danger and he may step out into an abyss, but his dog (animal nature) is gently warning him to be aware. The dog is contacting his master’s back, a place indicating the base chakra (muldahara) that connects with the earth.

Here we may stop and reflect about our dreams and dream symbols. Dreams connect us with that free floating energy that we perceive in the FOOL. As we meditate on our dream symbols, we become interested in the minute details of the dream symbols: what are they saying to us? So, like in dream work, let us take a moment to ask the FOOL to speak:

“Do you know that in every moment you may change your perception of reality?”

“Expand your field, do not rest and keep on traveling”

“Leave all beliefs that you have regarding others being better than you, stronger than you”

“It is not your purpose to lose consciousness, abandon freedom or give up”

“Let your inner madness guide you.”

“The spirit (intuition) that you have is your best teacher/guide.”

“Until now you have lived in the rational realm, not paying attention to other life energies. Become aware of the great ocean of unconsciousness”.

“Live fully and totally in body, mind and spirit”.

The Tarot is not only a divinatory tool but it also gives us guidelines to understand our own dreams. It gives us a clear view of both sides of human fate: the wonderful and the nightmarish.

Dreaming our reality

Some researchers of dreams have found that our minds naturally create stories around the facts of our lives and those personal stories strongly influence how we perceive ourselves as well as how we behave in real time. When recurrent themes are being felt as triumphs over adversities and how our troubles are resolved, we feel good and have a lot of courage. However, with stories that focus on the dark and negative results that destroyed our happiness, we are likely to experience fears, apathy and depression.

In addition to our personal dreams we share a collective dream based on social, spiritual and cultural scripts. We learned about ideas as to how we should live our lives and measure our worth and happiness. All collective nightmares created by others (wars, terror and evil) have a strong input into our own perception of reality.

This perception of nightmares is based on focusing on problems in all the digital media available today. All or most of our energy is spent on reading about, thinking about and noting world problems. What we need is to focus on and re-imagine a world that has harmony and wellbeing.  Have a vision beyond the collective nightmares (reflected in bad news) – we can actually dream this vision into being!

When we operate from a higher level of consciousness, we stop perceiving ‘problems’ and start perceiving ‘situations’ and opportunities that are neither good nor bad. They are simply here and now giving us a point of view from a creative awareness and then we begin to note opportunities in every dark space.

When we become paralysed in a nightmare, we lose any notion about how we can enjoy a sense of purpose and be free, like the FOOL in the Tarot card.

 
 
 
         Different representations of the Fool
 
 
 
The next post will give you a full understanding of dreams and nightmares from a gestalt perspective. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

DREAMS AND NIGHTMARES - A GESTALT HYPOTHESIS

This article is based on the writings of my good friend Martha Preciado, now deceased, who was the director of the Gestalt Institute of Guadalajara, Mexico. I was visiting Mexico in the 1990's and did some training in that Institute. Martha was a great leader and therapist and inspired many students, now graduates, to carry on the excellent gestalt tradition. I have the honour of translating her paper from Spanish and invite the reader to reflect on her ideas and give me feedback later.

 
DREAMS AS NIGHTMARES – A GESTALT HYPOTHESIS
            By
 
Martha L. Preciado – Translated from Spanish by Yaro Starak
 

Introduction

 
Working with dreams as a gestalt therapist gives me great personal insight as a human being and it also enables me to be in touch with my own magical/symbolic part.
It is also a wonderful opportunity to enable people to become more whole and more in touch with their existential self. When this happens, the person discovers more energy for living a fuller life, takes more risks or challenges in their daily life and for many it fulfils an inner purpose or destiny that life presents them.
As a gestalt therapist, I have often reflected deeply on the issues that our dreams place before us. Of particular interest to me are the dreams commonly called “nightmares” In my own experience and in the experience of many other psychotherapists the following are the basic questions that arise when we work with nightmares:
 
  • What do nightmares offer us?
  • What special messages does the nightmare send us?
  • Can we learn and develop further by working with our nightmares?
 
When I work with clients that present their dreams as nightmares, I find that they have a strong urgency to do something about their dream. They either want to get rid of these nightmares quickly or want to find out why they are coming to bother and frighten them.
Gestalt therapists often work with recurrent dreams and nightmares. The fundamental grounding literature about nightmares points out to the notion that nightmares consistently produce strong feelings of anxiety, fear and horror. They are experiences that often are related as some sort of horror movies.
However, such simplistic answers are not enough and as a result I began to focus my observations carefully on my clients’ nightmares in my own practice. My observations led me to the following hypothesis that will be elaborated in this article. First, let us review the question more specifically: “what are nightmares”?
 
What Are Nightmares?
Nightmares have at least two specific and distinguishing features:
 
(a)    They are charged with a high level of anxiety. This anxiety is experienced for some time, even after the nightmare is interrupted and the person is fully awake and
(b)   Nightmares bring about strong, frightening images but often, when a person awakens, he or she will not have any sense of fear or anxiety about them.
 
For example, a client reported a dream/nightmare and stated that she dreamt of a cup with red liquid and she was sure that this cup was full of human blood. After this nightmare the client had a major anxiety attack and was afraid to go to sleep.
Another client of mine presented the following image: She dreamt of a deformed, mutilated female body without legs or arms and was covered with wounds smelling quite putrid. However this client had no particular feelings about this dream when she spoke about it.
Although in the first case the dreamer had a strong reaction to her image, and while in the second case there was no affect present, both dream experiences can be classified as nightmares. In many cases nightmares are experienced following a traumatic event. Such an event may be an upsetting horror film, experiencing a shock, being in or watching an accident or having an unusual amount of stress in life which precipitates fears and worries.
For example, one client reported that after her divorce she had the following nightmare: “ I am at a café, sitting and reading a book. Suddenly a man enters holding a big knife in his hand. He begins to kill every customer in the café and I feel that he is going to kill me any moment now. I feel totally frozen and unable to move because of this horrible fear I have. I wake up in a sweat.”
 
Some Theoretical Reflections about Nightmares
Gestalt therapy has developed a special method of working with dreams that has a specific therapeutic outcome. Dream work is a subtle way of entering into the “magic” world of the client’s inner self. However, the therapist enters this world carefully not interpreting the meaning. Also without leaving behind the process of healing by using the therapeutic method.
The basic philosophy of gestalt dream work is to re-integrate the disowned (split) parts of the inner self with the purpose of promoting a healing of the whole person. We call this process ‘the holographic principle.’ We follow the assertion that the dreamer creates all parts of the dream. No one else is creating the dream. A dream is totally and fully our own production, our own drama and our own direction.
If this assertion is true, then all that constitutes a dream is our own projection phenomenon. Fritz Perls was the first proponent of this assertion. He stated that our own disowned parts of the self are expressing themselves in the dream as if it were a play on stage. However this principle is not as simple as it appears to be. Since we may identify with each of the parts in the dream, we also develop an automatic resistance to these parts. We will invariably resist the images in the dream that are not too attractive, pleasant or acceptable to us. For example we may ask; who wants to identify with a dirty pig, a killer, an evil or a horrible monster?
In the case of nightmares, where images are extremely frightening and negative, we naturally tend to refuse to confront such parts, let alone identify with them.  We experience these horrific images as a direct threat to our personal integrity and our own idea of sanity.
The second theoretical reflection is about the gestalt notion of “unfinished business”. This means that something is in the foreground of our awareness and the rest is in the background and hidden from our awareness. When an experience in our life is not complete (finished) the figure/background process tends to become rigid and develops a protective ‘guardian’ that may appear as a ‘solution’ to what has been an unfinished situation.
For example, if I am a child, and I am lacking the maturity and perspective in solving life’s problems, I am not able to handle the attacks upon me by my alcoholic or abusive father or other such difficult and painful situations. As a result of this trauma, I develop a protective pattern of splitting away from my body whereby I will not feel any pain when I get maltreated.
As I grow up this protective pattern is repeated again and again when I encounter what I perceive as abusive situations with others. In spite of the fact that many of these situations I can handle perfectly well as an adult, my early familiar pattern gives me immediate although temporary relief. In time this pattern may develop into what we call “a frozen gestalt” and become a compulsion, a neurotic habit, an addiction or become entrenched in body symptoms. In other words, I develop an avoidance pattern called retroflection.
Retroflection is an internal body symptom that emerges when we do to ourselves what we want to do to others. (I want to fight back and hit my father and instead I fight with myself).
In nightmares we often experience both phenomena at the same time – retroflection and projection. For example, I am dreaming that I am being violently attacked, dismembered and feel like a victim but also in this dream I am the aggressor who attacks and inflicts the pain. Now, what follows is my hypothesis as a result of my practice in working with nightmares.
 
Hypothesis
A scenario: There were times in my life that I experienced a traumatic or difficult situations in which I had a wish/desire/urge to retaliate or release my natural aggressive impulses. However my impulses were stopped by stronger or more powerful opponents. As a form of defence, I retroflected (turned against myself) my aggressive impulses and developed symptoms that enabled me to deal internally with the unfinished situations that required finishing outside myself. This repressed/aggressive energy I turned against myself and as a result I developed pseudo-solutions to my issues like self-hate, low self-esteem, self-mutilation, addictions and so on.
And so, while sleeping I begin to dream of being aggressive and project my aggressive impulses onto images that become so strong that they bounce back at me as nightmares. Thus the process of retroflection and projection goes in both directions – into/against me and out of myself and against others while I am asleep.
 
Working with Nightmares in Gestalt Therapy
Working with nightmares using the gestalt approach we often experience new resolutions to the problems presented by the dreams. Here is a brief description of the steps we undertake in such work:
  • A person narrates the nightmare in the present tense (here & now).
  • The therapist encourages the client to select an image that may be at this moment most significant, strongest or in the person’s foreground.
  • The client is encouraged to become more aware of the specific details of this image.
  • Invariably the aggressive (energetic) impulses will emerge and are explored in the here and now situation.
  • The feeling of excitement/anxiety may be amplified at this time in the context of the ‘safe emergency’ of this session.
  • The therapist enables the client to ‘stay in the present’ and encounter the dream image.
  • There may be an opportunity for a dialogue with this strong image, however, the mere facing the image may be enough.
  • The therapist pays particular attention to the emerging unfinished business in this encounter as it unfolds in the session.
  • There may be strong, aggressive language, powerful feelings, memories of earlier experiences, emotional release and so on manifesting itself as the blocked  energy is released behind the unfinished situation.
  • Next the therapist pays close attention to the retroflective patterns (e.g. Self-fulfilling prophecies) that may appear as a “frozen” figure, a sense of losing power or losing energy altogether. Here we may see the ‘impasse’ phenomenon.
  • The therapist does not attempt to change anything but simply supports this process as it is.(paradoxical theory of change).
  • When a strong figure emerges, from this impasse, the therapist encourages the client to re-identify with this figure.
  • In the supportive environment of the therapeutic session, the client is encouraged to identify with and take the position of the strong figure in the dream and make contact with it.
  • Having identified with this figure the client enters the dream once more and expresses him/herself fully as this dream figure, e.g. “I am the Devil!”  “I am the witch!” “I am the killer!” and so on.
  • The nightmare scenario is recreated again with the support of the therapist and work continues until the unfinished situation become complete and no longer threatens the client with nightmares.
As a working example, a client began to express images of a nightmare that appeared intransigent (uncompromising) and began to get stuck in a ‘frozen’ figure.  Suddenly a memory came up of a time when she was a teenager and in a relationship with an older man. She reported that he was often violent and abusive to her and this lasted several years. She felt powerless and stuck, unable to leave him. She also felt guilty and remorseful about the relationship.
In the nightmare she is watching a cement truck covering the streets not with cement but with a dead body that someone threw into the cement container of this truck. The truck was ‘cementing’ the streets with what she described as a “human mixture”.
The therapist recreated the dream asking her client to be the driver of that cement truck and put the man she felt abused by in her life in the container of this truck. While she identified with the truck driver she began to imagine that she is covering the streets with his material and his persona and began to shout: “yes, yes, it is him and he is in my truck” While she drove the truck in this recreated dream she began to say: “here I am cementing al my insecurities that are left from that time with him”, Now I am cementing all my fears of new relationships”……..and so on.
The therapist kept monitoring her feelings and supporting her strong ability to act both physically and emotionally in the new dream scenario.
After this enactment of the dream, the client stated that she felt rather strong, satisfied and happy about the way her life went on. She became more integrated in her relationship with others by not feeling so powerless in the presence of men. When asked what the nightmare’s existential message was for her she replied: “the dream said to me that it is time that you take charge of your life, you are strong and capable now and you can heal yourself!”
 
Conclusion 
Gestalt work with nightmares is mainly intra-personal; it enables a client to combine the left brain activity of the narrative and the right brain activity of the created images. In this way the person can develop new tools for living a full life.
By integrating our interior life we will be able to integrate fully our interpersonal world and increase our capacity to grow and relate with others more fully and in a new way.
In gestalt work with nightmares the outcome is often positive, the nightmares disappear and life becomes a joy to live.
In the meantime, the therapist must be in close contract with the client for some time to ensure that the inner process is no longer psychologically disturbing and that the client has fully finished what the inner world of dreams is presenting to him or her.
I trust that this short article and my hypothesis within, may be of some help to therapists that attempt to enter the world of the nightmare and shed some light on some of the least known, murky and shadowy aspects of psychotherapy.
 
References:
Ferud, Sigmund; 1948. “Introduction to Psychanalysis” part 3 in the “Dreams” section.
Perls, Fritz; 1974. “Dreams and Existence” Editorial 4. Vientos, Santiago de Chile Publisher.
 Downing, Jack & Marmorstein, Robert;  1973, “Dreams & Nightmares” Harper and Row publishers.
 
 


Fritz Perls by Otto Dix, artist.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


Sunday, March 20, 2016

REFLECTIONS ON GESTALT AND CONTEMPORARY THERAPIES


 
 
 
 
REFLECTIONS ON THE CONTEMPORARY THERAPIES

 

After some 35 years of teaching and the University of Queensland and training gestalt therapists all over the world, I am now reflecting on this so called “talking cures’ or as the contemporary writers call it “relational therapies”. 

Millions of people seek some sort of psychological help assuming (believing) that a professional will be able to sort out their complex life problems and/or at least help with their relationships.  However, the first question is how to select from a huge list of available therapeutical modalities that seem to mainly be interested in making money because there is no clear evidence that the “talking therapy” actually helps but there is some evidence that it can hinder solutions or create more problems to the many individuals, families and eventually to whole societies.

Take a brief look at history of humanity. Here we discover that prior to the emergence of therapies, spouses, parents, lovers, children, and all sorts of close friends and colleagues – that were not therapists – were considered the most important people in our lives and the most available to help. Now the many psychotherapies place the professional helper in the middle of the ‘lay folk’ and make the ‘expert’ the most important problem solver. Many who practice as a way of earning a living, deliberately promote themselves as the true expert in human relations and thus degrade what for centuries was a wealth of wisdom regarding human growth and development: the tribe, the family, the group and society.

Research reports about questionable results in therapy are usually criticised or simply ignored. As far back as 1952, H.J. Eysenck, a British psychologist, begun the practice of scientifically examining the effectiveness of psychotherapy with the ‘common neurotic person’, he compared the recovery rates of persons not treated with those treated with psychotherapy. He concluded that psychotherapy was ineffective promoting recovery from a neurotic disorder.

We know very well that there are a large amount of methods and techniques of psychotherapy and each claim specific results. Like psychoanalysis that helps to understand the nature of inner problems to Humanistic therapies that share and reflect on the clients’ feelings and emotions. CBT or behavioural techniques that instruct the client to stop negative patters of thinking and so on and on.

Nevertheless, in the many years of research, all the evidence points to only one factor that enables growth and helps with problems is: RELATIONSHIP. The client-therapist quality of relationship they experience in any sort of therapy. We may claim that our specific techniques or methods are effective in comparison to others, we cannot deny that the relationship between the client and therapist is key to developing a positive or negative outcome of therapy.

It is obvious, then, that any orientation that we may have chosen to be trained as a psychotherapist, the major skill is to learn how to develop a positive, conscious and ongoing relationship with the client in order to achieve measurable positive outcomes in therapy.

 
 
  
GESTALT AND THE CREATIVE PROCESS

In Perl's (1977) formulation of the goal of treatment, self-expression and awareness on the nonverbal level also play an important role:

The treatment is finished when the patient has achieved the basic requirements: change in outlook, a technique of adequate self- expression and assimilation, and the ability to extend awareness to the nonverbal level. He has then reached that state of integration which facilitates his own development, and he can now be safely left to himself to continue life as a healthy journey.

There are many new studies that carry the title of “Psychoneurology”, “Biopsychology”, “psychobiology” and so on. These studies use the new brain scanning technology to determine the therapeutic outcomes. At the 2014 GANZ (Gestalt Australia & New Zealand) conference in Brisbane a key note speaker was a brain researcher from the University of Queensland. He specifically outlined the positive therapeutic outcomes working with Gestalt Therapy. I felt overjoyed about this evidence because it finally acknowledged the many years of experience of working as a Gestalt therapist and trainer that this particular therapy does train practitioners to make clear and positive contact (relationship) with clients and groups. Gestalt also includes in its training a large input in creative experiential and experimental techniques.

The quote by James Dewar “minds are like parachutes, they only function when they are open” is a wise one. He suggests that books, theories and intellectual jargon only aims to keep the mind closed to experience. It is clear that all therapeutic orientations that span over 100 years now, are required to enable the client to “talk about” issues or problems and that is supposed to relieve them form psychological stress.

Only Dr. Fritz Perls and his wife Laura pioneered the notion of an authentic encounter with the client. They used many expressive therapies (including body work) that generated feelings of anger, sadness, disgust, joy, sexuality, etc. He often spoke to clients to “stop mind fucking” and experience the NOW! Perls worked in a small group format where he encouraged members to express , explore and share openly their inner feelings instead of ‘talking about’ them.

Talking about does not help to solve many problems deeply ingrained in human beings. It actually helps to fill out the ‘therapy’ hour creating an illusion for the client and therapist that something very important is happening.

Gestalt Therapy has deleted that illusion from its methodology and instead promoted the sense of AWARENESS. Awareness is a process that happens only in the here and now (present) and has the potential to shift the client’s life-space by enabling the understanding of deep relationship with the whole spectrum of personal, transpersonal, existential human growth.

One of the mayor developments in the Gestalt therapy field is the awareness of the creative process in healing Body, Mind and Spirit. Joseph Zinker pioneered this idea in his book: “Creative Process in Gestalt Therapy” (1978).
 
 
 Joseph Zinker

GESTALT AND JOSEPH ZINKER

 According to Zinker, Gestalt is a creative approach, which may include drawing, playing, dance and drama. The therapist will be willing to engage in a genuine relationship with the client, within appropriate therapeutic boundaries. Exploration of this therapeutic relationship will form an important part of the therapy. The therapist may set up an experiment to aid the client in more fully experiencing and expressing a current sensation or work with art tools like drawing, painting, mask making, sculpture, theatre, dance, collage etc.

Gestalt therapists believe that unfinished business underlies much human distress and will support clients in reaching resolution in those areas of their lives where they feel incomplete. This may involve the safe expression of pain, anger, sorrow, fear and joy. Often, relief follows the release of emotions which have been held back, especially if they have been held over a long period of time, perhaps because such expression would have been unsafe. Art tools enable the clients to put outside themselves what is inside and then can work on the figure presented in their art work.

Gestalt therapists further believe that all of us contain aspects which are loving, cruel, hostile, joyful, adventurous, timorous and so on. Integration occurs when we own and accept all that we are, rather than pretending to ourselves and others that we are always kind, or brave or hard-working or whatever. Thus the therapist will also support clients in discovering, exploring and reclaiming parts of themselves which they have disowned. Drama using puppets and sand tray are some of the most powerful methods to help the integration of dis-owned parts.

 Photo: Y. Sarak copyright
 
 
 [2]A BRIEF HISTORY OF ART THERAPY

Although art therapy is a relatively young therapeutic discipline, its roots lie in the use of the arts in the 'moral treatment' of psychiatric patients in the late 18th century, this moral treatment, Susan Hogan argues, “arose out of utilitarian philosophy and also from a non-conformist religious tradition”, and in a re-evaluation of the art of non-western art and of the art of untrained artists.

Art therapy as a profession began in the mid-20th century, arising independently in English-speaking and European countries. The early art therapists who published accounts of their work acknowledged the influence of aesthetics, psychiatry, psychoanalysis, rehabilitation, early childhood education, and art education, to varying degrees, on their practices.

The British artist Adrian Hill coined the term art therapy in 1942. Hill, recovering from tuberculosis in a sanatorium, discovered the therapeutic benefits of drawing and painting while convalescing. He wrote that the value of art therapy lay in "completely engrossing the mind (as well as the fingers) …releasing the creative energy of the frequently inhibited patient", which enabled the patient to "build up a strong defence against his misfortunes". He suggested artistic work to his fellow patients. That began his art therapy work, which was documented in 1945 in his book, Art Versus Illness.

The artist Edward Adamson, demobilised after WW2, joined Adrian Hill to extend Hill’s work to the British long stay mental hospitals. Other early proponents of art therapy in Britain include E. M. Lyddiatt, Michael Edwards, Diana Raphael-Halliday and Rita Simon. The British Association of Art Therapists was founded in 1964.

U.S. art therapy pioneers Margaret Naumburg and Edith Kramer began practicing at around the same time as Hill. Naumburg, an educator, asserted that "art therapy is psychoanalytically oriented" and that free art expression "becomes a form of symbolic speech which…leads to an increase in verbalization in the course of therapy. Edith Kramer, an artist, pointed out the importance of the creative process, psychological defences, and artistic quality, writing that "sublimation is attained when forms are created that successfully contain…anger, anxiety, or pain.” Other early proponents of art therapy in the United States include Elinor Ulman, Robert "Bob" Ault, and Judith Rubin. The American Art Therapy Association was founded in 1969.

National professional associations of art therapy exist in many countries, including Brazil, Canada, Australia, Finland, Israel, Japan, the Netherlands, Romania, South Korea, and Sweden. International networking contributes to the establishment of standards for education and practice. Diverse perspectives exist on history of art therapy, which complement those that focus on the institutionalization of art therapy as a profession in Britain, the United States and Australia.

The purpose of art therapy is essentially one of healing. Art therapy can be successfully applied to clients with physical, mental or emotional problems, diseases and disorders. Any type of visual art and art medium can be employed within the therapeutic process, including painting, drawing, sculpting, photography, and digital art. Art therapy stands in contrast with other kinds of creative or expressive arts therapies that use dance, music or drama. One of the major differences between art therapy and other forms of communication is that most other forms of communication elicit the use of words or language as a means of communication. Studies have demonstrated the efficacy of art therapy, as applied to clients with memory loss due to Alzheimer’s and other diseases; stroke residuals; cognitive functioning; traumatic brain injury; post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD); depression; dealing with chronic illness; and aging. However, the potential healing power of art therapy has not been thoroughly studied in certain patients, such as trauma victims with disorders such as PTSD. Art therapists report remarkable results from work with combat veterans, traumatized victims, sexual abuse survivors and survivors of natural disasters. Published case stories and research projects also support the efficiency of the approach. As art therapy grows in popularity and gains recognition, the purpose will become more clear and branch out to different patients. The purpose of art therapy is to provide a new healing opportunity to those who will benefit most from alternative therapy methods. In conclusion, art therapy is one of multiple methods to create peace and healing. Gestalt Art therapy has only recently developed and is growing.

PS: Watch this very informative talk by philosopher Alain de Botton: “Art as Therapy”



 
 

GESTALT ART THERAPY CENTRE

The Centre begun in 2008 when Yaro Starak and Gemma Garcia arrived from Spain. Both completed their training in Gestalt Therapy and Gemma received a diploma in Visual arts in Brisbane. Combining art therapy and gestalt was a project that opened opportunities for anyone who is interested in learning how to apply art tools in working as a gestalt therapist and also for those who were not trained in gestalt, to learn to become more proficient in their work. The fusion of both methods created the first Centre of Gestalt art therapy in Australia. The reader is invited to click on the links below and discover the story with all the details.




 





GUESS WHO ARE THEY? WHERE and  WHEN? (hint: GANZ)